Coffee klatch, Food science, Kitchen Fun, Water
Comments 21

Namaste and the three jars of rice and water: Experiment #2

"Love jar," "idiot jar" and ignored jar midway through the February experiment of sending love and gratitude thoughts to all three

Remember the rice, water and love experiment my granddaughter and I did in January? We didn’t stop there. We extended the experiment into February, with one difference: Instead of cursing the second jar and ignoring the third, we (or I most days) spoke only kindness to all three.

Could kind thoughts cleanse the rice and water in the two yukky jars and return them to a state similar to the “loved” jar? How would the rice and water in the first jar fare over another month? Would it spoil like its sisters? Stay the same? Improve?

Here’s how the rice looked on February 2.

3 jars of rice and water from the January experiment, each at different stages of fermentation and/or rot on February 2

3 jars of rice and water from the January experiment, each at different stages of fermentation and/or rot on February 2

The third grader held her nose when we checked on them, even before we lifted the lids. Her little sister wouldn’t come near them. When we opened the jars, we both squealed and gagged, covering our mouths and noses. The jar on the left, the “love jar,” didn’t seem that bad to me, wafting somewhat vinegary and sweet as it had a few weeks ago. The child disagreed. “It’s disgusting!” To her, fermentation smells no better than rot.

How the experiment changed in February

As you know, we started out in January with three identical jars of rice and water. Throughout January I spoke loving thoughts to the first jar. I’ve taken to calling it the love jar. The second jar received mean thoughts. I had trouble with that at first and eventually settled on “You idiot!” Hence, for purposes of this article, it is now the “idiot jar.” Following Dr. Masaru Emoto’s experiment in the film The Secret of Water, I ignored the third jar completely, neither looking at it nor speaking to it.

What was different this time around? In February, I projected loving thoughts toward all three jars, exactly the same each day.

Mid-month, the

Mid-month, the “love jar” appears to be fermenting still, while the water in the other two jars grows more brackish and fetid

At first, I planned to use the simple word, “Namaste,” with hands folded and a bow, just as one does after a meditation. Self discipline in short supply, apparently, I lingered longer than the single word would allow. Every day, in addition to bowing to the rice (Crazy-sounding, isn’t it?) and speaking the word, I also sent loving thoughts and gratitude, spending two to three seconds with each jar. Oh, and I smiled affectionately too. Couldn’t help that. Kindness almost automatically elicits a smile, wouldn’t you agree?

A wrinkle in time intent

Right off the bat, I struggled with the idea that my thoughts might set up a reaction that could kill the mold and bacteria in the “bad” jars. Who am I, the thought came, unbidden each day, to decide that the mold and bacteria in those jars is “wrong”or “bad”? They are, after all, living organisms. Yes, I’m that kind of person.

It took me to mid-month, to get comfortable with those thoughts, acknowledge them, much as one does in a meditation, and let them pass during my brief daily homage to the jar’s contents.

What happened to the rice and water?

Here’s how the jars appeared on February 27, near the end of the month. As you can see, this photo is nearly identical to the the two above, taken February 2 and February 13, respectively. Even the ripples around the edges retained much the same shape.

The same 3 jars of rice and water on February 27--the rice and water have a pinkish cast and are getting a little mushy on the bottom, especially the third jar on the right

The same 3 jars of rice and water on February 27–the rice and water have a pinkish cast and are getting a little mushy on the bottom, especially the third jar on the right

Surprisingly, very little water evaporated. In fact, the third jar contains more water. Could off-gassing as the rice broke down increase the water volume somehow? Why only in this jar?

Below the surface, as visible from outside the jars, the rice and water did not appear to change a whole lot either. All three developed a ring of mush at the bottom–just a little in the love jar, more in the idiot jar and nearly twice as much in the previously ignored jar. In addition, some of the rice in the jars took on a faintly pink tinge.

This slideshow, of the same three photographs, reveals just how little the three jars changed over the course of the second month.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The love jar remained basically clean. In fact, those strange waxy circles on top of the water diminished during February. The difference in coloration you see in the two photographs is due to taking them in different light. (Who is that woefully amateurish photographer anyway? Oh, right. It’s me. I’ll get better. I promise.)

(To zoom or to see the captions, click on one of the images.)

The other two jars changed a little in February, though not as much as expected. Here’s the “idiot” jar, looking down from above, at the end of January and again a month later. The waxy-looking “cells” around the edges appear to have liquefied. A pink tinge permeates the top. The rectangular, black mold clumps changed little.

Now take a look at the jar to which I paid no heed in January and, like the others, sent loving thoughts each day in February.

The moldy star-shaped pillows seem to have grown slightly thicker and appear more convoluted. The water is fetid, murkier.

What about the smell?

By the end of February, I was concerned about the odor. While not strong, it scented the air, vaguely unpleasant, each time I opened the back door. We share this common area with another apartment on this floor, as we share the rear stair well with all apartments on this side of the building. What did the neighbors think? I may never know. We’ve not met the people who share this back-door landing with us! City life.

On the last day of the month, I girded my gag-reflex loins, as it were, and in the interest of amateur science carefully removed the lids and took a whiff, one at a time. The love jar? Still not too bad. Not as pleasant now as at the end of January, and with an undertone of spoilage, it still smelled slightly sweet and vinegary. The other two jars? I nearly lost my cupcakes. Those babies had to go.

Conclusion and next steps

Clearly, my loving thoughts did nothing to cleanse the rice and water in the “bad” jars. But I couldn’t help wondering whether they may have inhibited spoilage and mold growth. Had I continued to curse and ignore, or simply let Nature takes its course, would the mold and rot have spread significantly?

What about the love jar? The contents deteriorated little in this second month as well.

Surprising outcome, don’t you think? So this month, since March 1, I have continued the love jar experiment, and added three new jars. Every day, I send the same loving thoughts to each jar–all four of them.

The original

The original “love jar” plus 3 new water and rice jars

Will sending kind thoughts to a new batch of jars produce the same results as last time? Will one, two or all three of the mixtures sprout mold or rot? Will they all stay fairly clean and untouched by bad bugs? How will the original love jar change?

What about fluctuating temperatures? The micro-climate in which these jars must sit changes daily, sometimes hourly. Temperatures can be near freezing one day and near eighty the next. Colder temps likely retard bacterial growth, preserving the rice, while warmer temps should promote fermentation and/or decay, right? And then there’s the love. We’ll see what happens.

Stay tuned for my April report on the March rice madness.


  1. Pingback: Love and 4 jars of rice and water: Experiment #4 | YayYay's Kitchen

  2. Pingback: Love and 4 jars of rice and water: Experiment #3 | YayYay's Kitchen

  3. Hi, Kathryn!
    You just commented on one of my posts, and I took a look at your website and came across this article! How fascinating! 🙂 I am a big fan of Emoto’s work, but then I heard it was just a big scam. Somehow, though, I never quite believed that! I’m looking forward to your April report on the rice! I’m so glad you did this with your grand daughter and that I had a chance to read it! 🙂 Made my day!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you. Found you on the Homesteader linkup and the feeling is mutual. I have a lot of questions about the “science” discussed in the film, but this experiment was so easy to do at home, it seemed worth a try. Our March experiment is turning out rather differently, so do check back in April for that report.


    • Thank you. Nice to see you here again. From the way the March experiment is going, I already have new questions for April, so looks like I’ll be doing this a couple more months at least.


  4. What an interesting experiment – I have heard of the water experiment before – it reminds me of the difficulty people have in finding scientific proof that Homeopathy works. I believe it does – and I use remedies when I am ill rather than take pharmecutrical preparations that often have side effects for me. However, other than the water holding on to a memory of the remedy there seems to be no other explanation at the moment of how they work. Usually scientists liken homeopathy as equivalent to taking an aspirin in a lake full of water and say it cannot possibly work and it must be the placebo effect. I used remedies on my cat – he could not perceive it as a placebo effect – he lived till he was 24 years old! I will be watching the rest of your experiment with interest.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you. As I recall, some of the researchers in the film were homeopaths, and I believe at least one of them described something similar regarding homeopathic medicines.


  5. Your original post sparked a long thoughtful conversation with my 9 year old granddaughter. First she didn’t believe it. Then she researched the experiment on the internet and decided it was authentic. Then she went back and forth about whether we should do it. She said she could never be mean to rice, but maybe I could. Then she decided she didn’t even want to cooperate in an experiment where I was being mean to rice. So thanks for the update on your experiments.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Please convey to your kindhearted granddaughter my sincere gratitude for her stand against meanness. We need more like her in this world. Perhaps she’ll be interested in the outcome of the March experiment, which I’ll publish in April, and which involves sending only kind thoughts to the “love jar” and three new jars of rice.

      May her beautiful heart ever lean toward kindness and love.


  6. Sharon L. Grace says

    This is so well written, it held my interest all the way through, and OMG how interesting to consider the impact simple, quick word can have… on rice. Imagine a word of “idiot” to a child, or ignoring a child. Better yet, imagine love and kind, caring, nurturing words. Your rice jars are a bit of a metaphor for our country today, don’t you think? Nicely done!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you Sharon. Glad to know you enjoyed it. Yes, I am interested in how loving thoughts–or not–might translate to the world crisis in which we find ourselves today. Absolutely.


  7. Your experiment has me thinking about sour dough starter. Once I get home, I’ll start a new batch (sadly, being away each winter means I can never keep my mother for long), and I’ll try to remember to send it loving thoughts and words. I wonder if that will affect the flavour or the rise of the resultant bread products.

    I look forward to next month’s report.

    Liked by 1 person

    • You know, Leah, since I did the first experiment, I’ve thought about that, too, and employed it, when I wasn’t distracted, while feeding my starter or kneading bread. With one loaf, I focused on loving thoughts the entire kneading time. Surprisingly, it was the tastiest levain I’ve made in awhile. Hope to have that kind of concentration this weekend and see if it happens again.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Barb. Well. I donned plastic gloves and a face mask like you use for sanding, poured and scraped them into a double-walled compostable bag, and put it in the compost bin. It’s all organic matter, after all. Thankfully, our city has a giant, commercial compost facility. If I had a garden, I’d have buried it in my compost pile.

      Liked by 2 people

I'd love to hear from you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.