Savory quiches, fruit pies, cream pies, rustic galettes, all good with this whole wheat crust
This is by far the best whole wheat pie crust recipe I’ve ever tasted. Boy is it good! Flaky, buttery, and with the wholesomeness and nutty flavor that only stone-ground, whole wheat flour can give.
Pack some extra vitamins, rich flavor and fiber into your pumpkin, mincemeat and other holiday pies when you make them with this nutritious crust.
In the springtime, enjoy a strawberry rhubarb lattice pie, made a little healthier with whole grain flour.
You’ll see my very first homemade strawberry-rhubarb pie later on this page, along with a link to the recipe (not mine this time) and a video showing the secret to making the lattice top.
Or fill this shell with a savory asparagus quiche, which you’ll also find later on this page, and step back and enjoy the oohs and aahs.
Oh yes, and it’s easy to make this pie vegan. Just substitute a half cup virgin, raw coconut oil for the butter. Do everything else the same. Your crust turns out beautifully!
Before we begin
Before we begin, a word about a new trick (for this old pie baker, anyway), a quick, fun poll and a few words about the tools I use.
If you’ve ever baked a pie, you probably know the first rule of thumb for a flaky crust is to chill all your utensils and ingredients. For years, I followed that rule, and it stood me in good stead.
A year or so ago, I learned a new trick from Maria Rodale on HuffPost Taste (Yes, my organic friends, that Maria Rodale.). I don’t know the science behind it, but this method really does make for an even flakier crust. Here’s the secret.
Start with softened butter. That’s right. Soft, room temperature butter.
Mix the dough and cut in the (soft) butter as usual, then chill the mixture thirty minutes before adding your ice-cold liquid.
While this method adds time to the overall process, you are free during those thirty minutes to pare the apples, stir up your filling, or get in a little aerobic exercise to burn off some of the calories you’re going to consume once that pie cools enough to eat.
If you have to soften your butter first (here’s a super easy way to do it), add an extra 15-20 minutes to complete the pie. If it’s already soft, you can mix the dry ingredients and cut in the butter in about five minutes.
Now for that poll. Take ten seconds and have some fun with this short poll!
Tools you need for fast pastry shell making
Using the right tools can make a difference between a trying task and a fun, successful one. Here’s a list of the tools that will make pie day fun and easy.
- Deep 1 quart mixing bowl
- Dry measuring cups and spoons
- Rolling pin, preferably tapered as you see in the photograph
- 9-inch pie plate or 10-inch quiche pan
Oh, and I like to brew a pot of tea to enjoy while the flour mixture chills.
Here you see the inexpensive, tapered beech rolling pin, without which rolling pie crust would be a drudge, along with the cobalt blue and white porcelain quiche pan I use for tarts too.
Blue not your color? Pick another!
Like so many foodies, I’m crazy about quiche pans. They make wonderful gifts for the foodies in your life, especially on Mother’s Day, birthdays or just-because, and are fun to collect. I keep track of my wish list over on HubPages here: Find the perfect quiche pan for the foodie in your life.
Enough of the preliminaries. Here’s the recipe!
YayYay's 100 percent whole wheat pie crust recipe
Whether you’re making a meringue-topped cream pie, a savory pot pie, a quiche or a rustic galette, you can always add a little extra nutritional goodness and taste with this whole wheat crust.
- 1/2 C Unsalted organic butter, preferably from grass-fed cows, cubed, and at room temperature (Tip: It’s easier to cube the butter while it’s cold) OR use 1/2 C organic, raw, virgin coconut oil
- 1-1/2 C Stone ground organic whole wheat flour
- 2 t Organic cane sugar
- 1/2 t Sea salt
- 4-8 T Ice cold water
- Sift the flour, then combine flour, sugar and salt, and sift again.
- With pastry cutter, cut softened butter into flour mixture until largest pieces are size of small peas. (Or pulse in food processor with chopping blade.)
If using coconut oil, add the measured, room-temperature (solid) oil to the flour mixture, cover with flour and cut in with pastry cutter as you would butter.
- Cover loosely with baker’s parchment and chill in refrigerator 30 minutes. Place a cup of water in the freezer to chill.
- Optional: At end of chill-time, if par-baking the crust, preheat oven to 450° F.
- Sprinkle 4-8 tablespoons ice water over mixture, 1 tablespoon at a time, tossing with a fork after each addition, until moistened just enough to hold together.
- While still in bowl, quickly form mixture into a ball, working dough as little as possible. To keep hands from warming the butter too much, use a silicone spoon-shaped spatula or wooden spoon to help bring the dough together.
- Lightly sift flour onto large piece of waxed paper or baking parchment or counter top. Flatten ball slightly, then roll it with your hand, like a wheel, along its narrow edge a few times. This helps to prevent the edges from tearing when you roll out the crust.
Wrap the paper around the flattened ball so it doesn’t dry out, and chill in the refrigerator 30 minutes. (3/27/16: Recently, I’ve discovered I can eliminate this step with no adverse effect.)
- Using a rolling pin, roll the flattened ball into a circle until it is about 1/8″ thick. To keep the dough from sticking to the paper or work surface during the roll-out, periodically lift and flip the dough. Sprinkle tiny amounts of flour over the surface sparingly, and only if needed to prevent sticking. Tip: Roll from the center to the edge, turning the waxed paper 1/8 turn with each roll of the pin.
- Fill and bake according to your favorite pie recipe. If par-baking for a custard or cream filling, spear bottom with a fork in 1-inch intervals, cover the edges loosely with aluminum foil or a pie ring to prevent scorching and bake in 450º F oven for 12-18 minutes.
This is a YayYay’s Kitchen original recipe. Please link back to this page if you base a recipe of your own on this one.
Ways to use this crust
These are some of the ways I fill my whole wheat crust. It’s not just for the holidays! Some are my own recipes. Others link to recipes on other sites. I use them all again and again. They’re that good. I should write some of them down! If ever those cooks take down their recipes, I’ll be out of luck.
Easiest pie ever isn’t a pie but a sugar-crusted galette
When you’re in a hurry and want a sweet treat, roll out your dough, slap a fruity filling in the middle, and fold the crust over the top, all the way round. Brush the pastry with milk or water-diluted egg white, sprinkle a little sugar over all and bake. Eye-popping deliciousness!
For handling ease with this galette, roll the dough out on a piece of parchment paper. Then lift parchment and all to a baking sheet. Alternatively, use a peel to pick up the filled pastry and slide it onto a baking sheet or pizza stone in the oven. Bake at your filling recipe’s recommended temperature.
Use this shell for your next quiche
Rich with a hand-made Gruyère cheese this asparagus quiche, with its dill-laced crust, is one of those dishes we look forward to every spring, as soon as the first tender shoots show up at our favorite green grocer and farmer’s markets.
Grandmom Price’s Rhubarb-Strawberry Pie
This is my first ever strawberry rhubarb pie. Grandmom Price is not my grandma, though I wouldn’t mind if she was. I found her recipe online, and we love it!
I don’t know why I’ve always felt intimidated by strawberry-rhubarb pie and lattice crusts, but I have, so one spring a while back, I decided to tackle both. Thankfully, Grandmom Price’s granddaughter is a videographer and got her grandmother’s permission to share her recipe and method with all of us. What a find!
Get Grandmom Price’s Rhubarb-Strawberry Pie recipe and watch her make her pie. She makes it look so easy, and surprisingly, it is!
You can see I have a lot to learn about making a pretty lattice crust, especially crimping the edges. They got mighty thick! Thankfully, the crust is flaky enough, we didn’t mind. I have to tell you, this is the best strawberry rhubarb pie I’ve ever had–and I’ve had lots.
Fabulous Banana Cream Pie in a whole wheat pie shell
While I’ve made quiches for years, I always left the pies to more experienced cooks.
My sweet mother-in-law made absolutely the best pies in the world, and she always made two or more so she could serve up a quarter of a pie to every guest. Talk about calories! Since I’ve retired, I’ve had a hankering for her pies. Now she’s gone, I had to start experimenting.
This is my first attempt at banana cream pie. Boy, did six of us nosh it down fast! The whole wheat crust is superb with the creamy custard. Here’s a link to the filling recipe I used: Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie at Food.com. This recipe from All-Recipes.com made the high-volume meringue: Meringue II, by Saundra.
Novice Baker? Or feel a bit intimidated by whole wheat?
Check out my photo tutorial, How to make a flaky, whole wheat pie crust, with photographs every step of the way. Then practice, practice, practice.
No better time than the holidays approaching to practice your baking skills. To achieve ever flakier and better whole wheat crusts, bake often. White flour is highly processed and has additives to help it provide uniform results every time you bake. Because whole wheat literally consists of ground whole grain, lots of variables can affect the outcome.
Did you know that changes in humidity and temperature in your home can affect your whole grain flour?
Hot, humid weather can change how your flour reacts to the moisture you add, as well as how much you need. So can cold weather, or a kitchen filled with hot, dry winter heat.
Always add just enough moisture to get a supple, strong dough. With time and practice, you will learn when you need to add a little more and when to add less.
The more you bake, the more you intuit the tiny tweaks you need to adjust for these variables from one baking day to the next.
What do you think?
Did you–or will you–try a whole wheat pie crust? Whole wheat pastry isn’t for everyone, but you’d be surprised the converts I’ve made with this recipe. I’d love to hear what you think.
♥ ♥ ♥
If this recipe is familiar to you, it may well be! I first published a version of this article on the now-defunct Squidoo under the username Giddy Gabby, and later still on Squidoo, under the name Graceonline. When HubPages bought Squidoo in 2014, I moved this page there, and in June 2015, here to YayYay’s Kitchen, with significant updates.
Last updated: 3/27/16